Butterball Turkey “BST” Burgers with Basil Jalapeño Aioli

Turkey BST Burgers.jpg

You know when you’re out to eat and you just can’t decide what to order? My biggest meal decision is often between the burger and the BLT. And sometimes I get just plain bitter I have to decide between the two. Sometimes I consider ordering two things, but I always have issues thinking I can eat EVERYTHING and must order the entire menu ASAP before I actually start eating a meal and realize, um, I really can’t eat as much as I think it can. Especially when I order a mountain of nachos for an appetizer. Or calamari. But that’s neither here nor there. I’m talking about tough menu decisions.

And that’s precisely why I enjoy combining some of my favorite foods. At first glance, a burger and a BLT are not very difficult to combine as you can basically add some bacon to a burger and call it a day. But come on, now, a true BLT has a healthy slathering of mayonnaise, a condiment we rarely see on burgers, at least not here in America. So, whip yourself up a quick aioli and add a little spice to it if you’re like me. I used spinach instead of lettuce because I always have it in my fridge. And I doubled up on the turkey with both the burger and the bacon. If Butterball’s goal was to truly turn me into the most ridiculous Turketarian ever than I think they have succeeded. Well done, Butterball. Well done.

Butterball Turkey “BST” Burgers with Basil Jalapeño Aioli (makes 2 burgers):
Print this recipe!

  • 1 batch basil jalapeño aioli (recipe below)
  • 6 slices Butterball Turkey Bacon
  • 2 Butterball Turkey Burgers
  • 2 burger buns
  • 2-3 tomatoes
  • 1 C spinach

Basil Jalapeño Aioli:
Print this recipe!

  • 1/2 C mayonnaise
  • 1 jalapeño pepper, roughly chopped with seeds removed
  • 1 clove garlic
  • 2 T basil

Turkey BST Burgers Ingredients.jpg

I know I’m working with Butterball and all, but I wouldn’t lie to y’all. And when I say this turkey burger is the most tender, juicy burger I’ve had in a long time, I absolutely mean it. I had no clue turkey burgers could taste so good, but now that I know, I’m never looking back. Never ever.

Not only do I love the burgers, but I’m also majorly impressed with their packaging. Since Reynolds is a partner of Butterball, they designed the burger packaging- the burgers come in a lovely re-sealable freezer bag. This makes me happy for many reasons, one being that I have way too much experience with freezer burn and this bag means my burgers will not get freezer burn. Plus, they’re kind of pretty as far as these kinds of things go. And I think you know you’re old when you write an entire paragraph about a freezer bag and still feel as though you have more to say. I’ll just stop now.

Turkey BST Burgers Turkey Breast Bag.jpg

Anyway, let’s make the aioli first. Place your mayonnaise, jalapeño, garlic clove, and basil in a blender or food processor and blend until smooth.

Turkey BST Burgers Jalapeno Basil Aioli.jpg

Remove to a small bowl and keep in the fridge until ready to use.

Turkey BST Burgers Jalapeno Basil Aioli Done.jpg

Now, let’s get our bacon on. This time, I decided to cook my turkey bacon low and slow. I put my six slices on a griddle over low heat and let it cook for about 30 minutes.

Turkey BST Burgers Bacon.jpg

I also sprinkled it with a little bit of tellicherry pepper and fenugreek, which is a little trick my dad taught me. I flipped it a few times while it cooked up and got nice and crispy.

Turkey BST Burgers Bacon Seasoned.jpg

While the bacon was cooking, I brushed my burgers with a little olive oil and placed them on my grill pan over medium heat. I cooked on one side for about 5 minutes and then flipped and cooked for another 5-7 minutes, until the inside registered 165 degrees on a meat thermometer.

Turkey BST Burgers Cooking.jpg

Perfectly cooked with the perfect grill marks! All done from my stovetop.

Turkey BST Burgers Burgers Grilled.jpg

I toasted up my buns a bit because there really isn’t anything better than a toasted bun when it comes to enjoying a burger.

Turkey BST Burgers Buns Grilled.jpg

I got my aioli out of the fridge and generously spread it on each of the buns.

Turkey BST Burgers Aioli Spread.jpg

Then I put the burgers on the buns and topped with bacon.

Turkey BST Burgers Build 1.jpg


Turkey BST Burgers Build 2.jpg

And spinach.

Turkey BST Burgers Build 3.jpg

I put the top of the bun on and called it a day.

I might have even called it the best day ever.

Turkey BST Burgers 5.jpg

I’m sorry, but can’t you tell just by looking at that burger how tender and juicy it is? I know I already said it, but these turkey burgers are like heaven. If you think turkey is dry and tasteless, try these. And your mind will be changed!

Turkey BST Burgers 8.jpg

Don’t you think it’s funny how some people claim to hate mayo, but call it an aioli and they get all swoon-like? Pshh I won’t call you out because I get it. I totally get it. This isn’t even really a true aioli, but I’m going with it and you should, too.

Turkey BST Burgers 6.jpg

Everyone knows bacon makes everything better, so turkey bacon on a turkey burger must be enough to make the world explode, right? Well, pretty much. It added the perfect crunch to the burger and a little bit of saltiness to offset the tomatoes and spinach.

Turkey BST Burgers 2.jpg

Turkey overdose? No such thing. And I actually made these burgers again a couple nights later. Because I got home from work and was tired and didn’t feel like thinking and I remembered how simple and fast these were to make. And so I spent 15 minutes in my kitchen and came out with these, which I gobbled up. Get it, gobbled?

And now I never have to make that super tough menu decision again. Because it’s sitting in my freezer. And fridge. Yum.

How would you top your turkey burger?

Check out the free Butterball Cookbook Plus app for more recipe ideas and Instagram for behind the scenes look at all things turkey.


20 Responses to "Butterball Turkey “BST” Burgers with Basil Jalapeño Aioli"

  1. Monica says:

    Nice combination – we’re big turkey fans in this house!

  2. Odetta says:

    There’s nothing better than a turkey burger that is actually juicy. Or topped with bacon!

  3. Megan says:

    Funny you should ask about how I’d top my turkey burger… wait til you see my post tomorrow. 😉 This combo sounds great. I have to admit that I don’t love mayo but I do love aioli. I’m one of those people.

  4. Melissa says:

    Sues, you are my savior! I have so many leftover jalapenos (You know how you have to buy a whole box at Trader Joe’s?) and I had no idea what to do with them. These look so good!!

  5. Jenn says:

    The burger looks great… but I must admit.. what really grabbed my attention is the basil jalapeno aioli!!! YUM!!!

  6. Monique says:

    That looks awesome! And I love a good aioli! Spoon, please? lol

  7. Victoria says:

    Yum! I too have a serious problem making decisions in restaurants, and I love the idea of sampling both items 🙂 These burgers look fantastic. I don’t usually like making pre-packaged burgers, but if you say they are moist and delicious, I will believe you 🙂

  8. oh delish! what a great burger 🙂

  9. I seriously might make that aioli tonight. Looks and sounds delicious!

  10. Gia Grossman says:

    I love a good burger! Since turkey makes it a little bit healthier, does that mean I can eat more?? 😉

  11. So many good flavors – spicy, salty, herby – going on here. Love how you dressed the turkey burger up!

  12. Juliana says:

    Like the idea of all turkey…and the aioli sounds delicious in this burger.
    Have a great weekend 😀

  13. Tara says:

    Wooooow, this should NOT be the first thing I wake up to! Now I will be craving all day. Is there anything you can recommend instead of mayo for the aioli? My bf will not eat it at any cost and I want him to try it!

  14. This burger looks right up my alley–yum! I like how it’s turkey on turkey too, haha. Aioli… mmmm…

  15. Love this tasty, healthy twist on traditional bacon burgers! Totally scrumptious!

  16. Joanne says:

    I have restaurant ordering issues also. Can I help it if I always want ALL THE THINGS. Way to combine two awesome things into one MONSTER awesome thing.

  17. Sues says:

    @Tara Hmm I’m always a sucker for ketchup… This soy-spiked ketchup totally caught me eye!

  18. Bree (Skinny Mommy) says:

    Love all your toppings on this–yum!

  19. alex says:

    I have the hardest time ordering at restaurants! I want everything! I love mayo on my burger! it is a much for a BLT! this looks like it would be a hit with me!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *