Caramelized Banana an Peanut Butter Sandwiches Recipe | We are not Martha
Jump to Recipe

Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches

You can never go wrong with a peanut butter sandwich, but lunchtime will be a whole lot more delicious with Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches instead!

Head-on view of a caramelized banana and peanut butter sandwich cut in half on a white plate with a second sandwich, bananas, and peanut butter jar in the background and recipe title at the top

Oh, hi there. It’s been a little while. I just returned from a absofabulawesome trip to California and I’d be lying if I didn’t say I wasn’t a little sad to be back in cold snowy Boston (it was 70 degrees in San Fran and wine country every day we were there). And I haven’t quite come to terms with the fact that I have to go back to work tomorrow. Which means I have to be up at 6:00 a.m., which is going to feel like 3 a.m. to my poor west coast accustomed body. But trust me, I am not complaining because the trip was pretty perfect and well, I’m sure I’ll be writing a blog post or two about it. Especially about my dinner at French Laundry (and the fact that they invited me and Chris into the kitchen after our meal!!!). But for now, I’m going to talk about sandwiches. And peanut butter sandwiches at that.

I actually had quite a few posts planned for when I was away, but then things got super busy at work and I didn’t end up having time to schedule them. So, I decided to just go off and enjoy my vacation and get posting when I returned! Back in college, one of my all-too-often meals was grilled peanut butter and banana sandwiches. I started thinking about them a couple weeks ago and then started craving them. So simple, but so comforting and perfect for when you want something easy or lunch or dinner. Or when you just get home from a super indulgent awesome vacation and just want something easy and satisfying.

CARAMELIZED BANANA AND PEANUT BUTTER SANDWICHES RECIPE

Let’s face it, there’s nothing difficult about a banana and peanut butter sandwich. I decided to caramelize the bananas in this version for a little extra kick, but if you’re feeling lazy (like I am nine times out of ten), just slice them up, obvi. Dinner will be on the table in no time at all. But even caramelizing the bananas doesn’t add too much time or difficulty… And it really does make a delicious difference!

Simply slice the bananas in half lengthwise and brush them with a melted butter and brown sugar mixture. And then caramelize in a grill pan (or regular pan)  over medium heat for a minute or two on each side, until golden.

Collage showing process for making caramelized banana and peanut butter sandwich, including bananas sliced lengthwise, bowl of melted butter and brown sugar, and butter/sugar mixture slathered on bananas on grill pan

Try your hardest not to gobble the caramelized bananas up right away. You need them for the banana and peanut butter sandwich! But they sure are pretty.

Overhead view of caramelized bananas on white plate

I put my bread slices on the grill for 2 minute per side to get a nice toasty-ness on them. And then slathered on the peanut butter and layered up the caramelized bananas. Don’t forget to drizzle on some honey for some extra sweetness. This isn’t absolutely necessary, but I LOVE honey on peanut butter sandwiches.

Overhead view of a slice of grilled bread with peanut butter and caramelized bananas on top

Slice that banana and peanut butter sandwich up and dinner is served. Or lunch. This is obviously a bit more appropriate for lunch, but like I mentioned, it’s perfect for a ridiculously easy and delicious dinner. But maybeeee you should serve a veggie or two on the side. Just sayin’.

Landscape view of caramelized banana and peanut butter sandwich sliced in half on a white plate with bananas and peanut butter jar in background

I love when the peanut butter gets all warm and melty. Omg yum. I kind of feel like I need to make this caramelized banana and peanut butter sandwich every day for lunch just to see how long it takes me to get sick of it. I’m pretty sure the answer to that would be NEVER. And if I did, I’d just add a little jelly or fluff or something. Can you even imagine fluff?? Things are getting out of control.

Can we just keep telling ourselves that bananas make this sandwich healthier? OK and more sugary, too.

Head-on view of a caramelized banana and peanut butter sandwich cut in half on a white plate with a second sandwich, bananas, and peanut butter jar in the background

When I woke up on the morning we were leaving California, I swore I’d never eat again. Like ever, ever again. Then I realized that was totally unreasonable and that I’d probably just eat vegetables and fruits and drink green juices. But then I started this post and this sandwich looks pretty darn perfect to me. And then Chris brought me home buffalo wings for dinner and I ate them. So, there goes that.

I’m in bed now because I KNOW I have to get to sleep even though my body doesn’t want to. If I had a fresh loaf of bread and bananas in my kitchen right now, I would actually get out of bed to make a banana and peanut butter sandwich again. As it is, I’m considering eating a scoop of peanut butter off a spoon (can you tell I haven’t been to the grocery store since I’ve been back?). But I just brushed my teeth and I. need. to. go. to. sleep.

Tomorrow. There’s always time for more food tomorrow.

What are your favorite peanut butter sandwich add-ons?

If you’re looking for more great sandwich recipes, check out my Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese or my Open-Faced Prosciutto and Plum Sandwiches.

Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches
Prep Time
10 mins
Cook Time
5 mins
Total Time
15 mins
 

You can never go wrong with a peanut butter sandwich, but lunchtime will be a whole lot more delicious with Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches instead!

Course: Entree, lunch
Cuisine: American
Keyword: Banana, Peanut Butter, sandwich
Servings: 2 sandwiches
Author: Sues
Ingredients
  • 2 medium bananas
  • 2 Tbsp unsalted butter, melted
  • 2 Tbsp brown sugar
  • 4 slices bread (I like brioche or challah)
  • 4 Tbsp peanut butter
  • 1 tsp honey
Instructions
  1. Cut bananas in half and slice them lengthwise.

  2. In a small bowl, mix together melted butter and brown sugar. Slather the mixture all over the bananas and place the bananas on a grill pan (or regular pan if you don't have one) over medium heat.

  3. Cook until the bananas are golden brown, 1-2 minutes and then flip to caramelize the other side, about 1 additional minute. Remove bananas to a plate.

  4. Place bread slices on the grill for 2 minute per side to give them a nice toasty-ness.

  5. Slather the peanut butter on all of the bread slices and layer the banana over the top of two slices. Drizzle the honey on top of the banana, sandwich together with the remaining bread slices, and cut in half.

Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches -- You can never go wrong with a peanut butter sandwich, but lunchtime will be a whole lot more delicious with Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches instead | wearenotmartha.com #peanutbutter #bananas #sandwiches #caramelilzed

17 Responses to "Caramelized Banana and Peanut Butter Sandwiches"

  1. Gia Grossman says:

    This is such a fun sandwich! Simple but one that I never think of!

  2. Nicole @ Young, Broke and Hungry says:

    This sandwich is my comfort food and what I always reach for when I am feeling down. I’m happy to hear you had a great time in wine country.

  3. Leah | So, How's It Taste? says:

    Look at that peanut butter oozing out! I’d love to have this for lunch today! Can’t wait to hear more about your trip!

  4. Michelle Lahey says:

    This looks SO good. And I love Teddie Peanut Butter!

  5. Just bought a jar of Skippy Natural. I’m sure it would taste good in this recipe too!

  6. Megan says:

    All Skippy all the time here! This sandwich looks awesome. And I cannot wait to read about your trip, especially TFL!

  7. Get this sandwich in my belly! I love Peanut Butter and Co, I tend to always stick with them, yum yum yum.

  8. Odetta says:

    Love the oozy PB! Skippy is my go to also!

  9. sarah k @ the pajama chef says:

    looks awesome! i used to make banana, pb & chocolate chip (or sometimes marshmallow) quesadillas when i’d get home from night class in grad school…but never caramelized! must try this 🙂

  10. Meghan says:

    This looks so easy and decadent! I actually really like TJ’s brand pb.

  11. We both posted about PB and banana today! I would love this, especially with the caramelized bananas.

  12. Ashley | Spoonful of Flavor says:

    This is one of my favorite things to make for lunch. I love the combination of chocolate and banana!

  13. Deanna says:

    So making this for lunch tomorrow (or maybe even for breakfast!

  14. Jodi says:

    Elvis’ favorite sandwich? Our favorite peanut butter is Organic Skippy Chunky Peanutbutter.

  15. cquek says:

    Yum! This looks gorgeous! I love skippy.

  16. Amy (Savory Moments) says:

    This looks like a great comfort food lunch or dinner!

  17. Lauren at Keep It Sweet says:

    Um yes, this is my kind of sandwich! I’m also sad to be back but can’t wait to hear about your French Laundry experience!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *