Everything Bagel Salmon Recipe | We are not Martha
Jump to Recipe

Everything Bagel Salmon

With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner!

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

If I’m going to eat a bagel, it needs to be a really good bagel. Or a just OK bagel, but a bagel that’s packed with a) cream cheese or b) bacon, eggs, AND cheese. I also prefer one of three varieties of bagels: 1) jalapeño cheddar, 2) french toast, or 3) everything. I think there are probably some exceptions and probably bagel varieties that I haven’t even been introduced to yet, but as of today, those are my bagel standards. If these bagel standards can’t be met, I’d really just prefer a donut, thank you very much. Everything bagels are a little strange (let’s just throw everything on a bagel!) and not even really literally everything (after all, you don’t find little french toast bits… or raisins on everything bagels), but so, so delicious. I’m guessing it’s mostly because of the garlic and onion and I’m totally OK with that.

While on our recent vacation in Maine, Chris and I had dinner at Perkin’s Cove’s Northern Union. On the menu was Everything Bagel Salmon and I thought “omg best idea ever!” However, I didn’t order it, mainly because Lobster Squid Ink Gnocchi was also on the menu and when in Maine and all. But I couldn’t get it out of my head and one of the first things I did when I got home from Ogunquit was to make my own version of Everything Bagel Salmon. It’s ridiculously easy and perfect for a healthy weeknight dinner.

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

All this dinner requires is mixing up a quick spice mix, which, let’s be honest, you may as well make a huge batch of to always have on hand for emergency situations, and baking your salmon. I highly recommend serving the salmon over rice with a nice healthy portion of vegetables on the side… I went with asparagus and grape tomatoes.

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

I try to fit a good amount of salmon into my diet since I love it and it’s so healthy, so I’m always on a quest to find fun new salmon recipes. I was thrilled that this one came out so wonderfully and I’ll be adding it to my make-again list!

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

There’s no denying that everything bagel spice rocks, but it’s so ridiculously delicious on more than just bagels (I mean, you can even buy a bottle of everything bagel spice a the grocery store!)

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

And OK, I can admit that a piece of salmon is not the same as a bagel. I mean, carbohydrates are carbohydrates after all. But you know you’re trying to cut back on carbs anyway (right??) and when you replace them with something totally healthy like salmon, but still get all the flavor of an everything bagel, I consider that a total win.

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

Is this making anyone else just plain crave an everything bagel with smoked salmon?? I’m actually not a huge smoked salmon fan (one of the few foods I’m just not that into), but even I feel like I’m going to need to find one for breakfast tomorrow.

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

In the meantime, I’m adding this Everything Bagel Salmon to my regular weeknight dinner rotation and dreaming about what else I can start putting that everything bagel spice on.

So, now who is going to talk me out of french toast salmon? Don’t worry… Jalapeño cheddar might be next on my list!

If you’re looking for other delicious salmon recipes, be sure to check out my Chili Lime Salmon Over Coconut Rice.

What’s your favorite kind of bagel and would it pair well with salmon?

Print
Everything Bagel Salmon
With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner!
Course: Entree
Servings: 2 servings
Author: We are not Martha
Ingredients
  • 2 6 oz. salmon filets (about 3/4 pound salmon)
  • 1 Tbsp Olive oil
  • Everything Bagel Spice (recipe below)
Everything Bagel Spice:
  • 1 Tbsp sesame seeds, lightly toasted
  • 1 Tbsp poppy seeds
  • 1 1/2 tsp black sesame seeds, lightly toasted
  • 1 1/4 tsp minced garlic
  • 1 tsp onion powder
  • 1/2 tsp coarse sea salt
Instructions
  1. Pre-heat oven to 375 degree and line a large baking sheet in foil.
  2. Lay salmon on baking sheet skin-side-down (if salmon has skin) and brush lightly with olive oil.
  3. Sprinkle Everything Bagel Spice over salmon and use fingers to gently press down.
  4. Place salmon in the oven and bake for about 15-20 minutes, depending on thickness of salmon, until salmon easily flakes with a fork or registers at 145 degrees.
  5. Serve salmon over rice with vegetables on the side.
Everything Bagel Spice:
  1. In a small bowl, mix together all ingredients.
Recipe Notes

Inspired by: Northern Union restaurant

Everything Bagel Salmon -- With all the flavor of an everything bagel, this Everything Bagel Salmon is a whole lot healthier and the perfect easy weeknight dinner! | wearenotmartha.com

14 Responses to "Everything Bagel Salmon"

  1. We all love salmon around here and I always appreciate new ways of making it! Delicious!

  2. Corina Blum says:

    The coating on the salmon sounds delicious and it’s such a healthy meal too. I also like to try and eat salmon as often as I can although unfortunately the rest of my family prefer white fish.

  3. I love salmon and I got addicted to everything bagels when I was living in the US. You don’t really get them over here but now I have the recipe for the spice mix I’m going to use it on everything!

  4. Fan of salmon here too and I absolutely love love love sesame seeds so this spice mix is right up my alley! I would happily have this over a bagel any day 😉

  5. Ellen says:

    I always love finding new recipes for salmon. This looks delicious.

  6. Genius! This is such a fantastic idea. I love everything bagel seasoning! Shhhh: I put some on popcorn!

  7. Well I love everything bagels and salmon, so this is win for me. Perfect as a weeknight dinner, yet awesome to feed company too.

  8. Victoria says:

    What an awesome and creative idea! Salmon is one of our most-cooked fishes so I’m always looking for different ways to prepare it. This is definitely going on the list 😉

  9. I’ve got salmon in my refrigerator right now that I was planning on making for dinner! I’m like you, lots of cream cheese on an everything, or jalapeno cheddar bagel. But I want it to be a GOOD bagel too, which can be hard to find in the south. I made them myself once and had bagels coming out of my ears for weeks lol.

  10. We eat so much salmon and I’m always looking for a new way to prepare it… I think an everything bagel mix is a great option!

  11. Salmon bagels are my best, but with smoked salmon, cream cheese and capers. And maybe a little bit of dill. We don’t get fresh salmon here so I am looking forward to eating it next month when we are in Scotland.

  12. This is AMAZING! Who knew there was everything bagel spice mix? Love it Sues!

  13. I’m right there with you…bagels need to be really good for me to eat them! I’ve been seeing everything bagel seasoning everywhere, so this salmon is right up my alley. Love that you made your own seasoning, too!

  14. Sharon Anderson says:

    Looks like a real celebratory dinner..Fantastic job Sues!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *