Apple Pie Ice Cream Fall Recipe | We are not Martha
Jump to Recipe

Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel and Pie Crust Cookies

This Apple Pie Ice Cream has all the elements of your favorite seasonal treat: apple pie filling, apple cider caramel, and pie crust cookies. It will convince you to keep your ice cream machine out all fall and winter long!

(This recipe for Apple Pie Ice Cream was originally posted in November 2014, but has been updated in 2018).

 

Head-on view of a bowl of apple pie ice cream drizzled with cider caramel and topped with a heart-shaped pie crust cookie with bowl of apple cider caramel in background and recipe title at top

There are some things about being an adult that are just no fun. For instance, no longer being able to stay up ridiculously late. Or having more than a couple glasses of wine in one sitting. I mean, I can obviously still do these things, but not without wanting to die for precisely 24 hours after following the event. And then feeling like I wasted an entire day of my life lying in bed recovering. It’s just not fair. My biggest new “being an adult stinks” realization is that I can’t eat spicy food the way I used to. And spicy food is pretty much my favorite thing in all the world. The whole world. Getting old is lame.

But I’m so, so thankful that I haven’t developed any intolerances to lactose thus far in my life (I’m knocking on a giant piece of wood and silently freaking out over the possibility). Because that means that I can enjoy ice cream to the fullest extent and not have to worry about a thing… Besides gaining a bunch of pounds. I know “official ice cream season” is over (wah!), but I actually think I make the least amount of ice cream in the summer. There are so many fall seasonal flavors I’m a fan of and I just can’t resist keeping my ice cream maker churning throughout the colder months. One of my very favorite fall flavors is that of apple pie. So, I turned it into an ice cream with this Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel and Pie Crust Cookies. This fed my ice cream and my apple obsession all at once.

APPLE PIE ICE CREAM WITH CIDER CARAMEL RECIPE

OK, let’s get one thing straight before we start… This recipe has a lot of steps. A lot. But please don’t be overwhelmed! First of all, homemade ice cream needs a longgg time in the freezer with two separate rounds of chilling. Also, you can easily make the caramel and pie crust cookies ahead if you want. The caramel should last a couple weeks in the fridge and the cookies a couple days in an airtight container. Also? All of the steps are totally worth it for this delicious goodness!!

But. If you really aren’t into putting in all the work, I have a couple shortcuts for you! You can buy jarred caramel sauce… It probably won’t be apple cider caramel (unless you know a store that sells it… If so, please inform me!), but it will work just fine. You can also buy pre-made pie crust dough and simply cut your own shapes in it. Or even just serve the ice cream with different cookies. Basically, just do whatever you need to do to get this ice cream on your table!

Firs things fist… Make the apple pie ice cream! This requires a few steps… The first is basically making an apple pie filling (yum!).

Collage showing process for making apple pie filling for ice cream, including photo of apples, sugar, cinnamon, and flour in pan and photo of cooked apple pie filling

And then making the custard-based ice cream and stirring in the apple pie filling and the cider caramel as it’s churning.

Collage showing process for making apple pie ice cream, including milk and sugar in saucepan, eggs and milk tempering in bowl, and ice cream with caramel and apple pie filling churning in ice cream maker

The caramel is a pretty basic recipe, but it includes stirring in cinnamon and a little bit of apple cider at the end. This turns a delicious caramel into an “omg I want to eat you with a spoon” caramel.

Collage showing apple cider caramel making process, including caramelized sugar and butter in saucepan, caramel bubbling in saucepan, and caramel in mason jar

I love making pie crust; it’s almost therapeutic to me. For this recipe, you make a basic pie dough, let it chill and then roll it out, cut out whatever shapes you want, sprinkle with some cinnamon sugar, and bake.

Collage showing process for making pie crust cookies, including bowl food processor with flour and cinnamon, bowl of chopped chilled butter, and pie crust wrapped in plastic wrap

I made little hearts, but apples would also be cute. If this step is just one step too far for you, buy an already made pie crust dough and cut out your shapes. Or serve with any store-bought cookies you want (ahem, Oreo makes an Apple Pie variety)!

Heart-shaped pie crust cookies sprinkles with cinnamon and sugar on a baking pan ready to be baked

Um, are we ready to serve our ice cream yet? Please?? OK, sure!

Top every dish of apple pie ice cream with a little extra drizzle of caramel and a pie crust cookie. I crumble one of the cookies over the top, too. The results? You’ll kind of feel like you’re eating apple pie a’la mode. But even better? I’m actually not a big fan of apple pie a’la mode (I don’t really have many weird food aversions, but for some reason, I just don’t want ice cream near my pie, thank you very much) and I was a gigantic fan of this dish of ice cream.

Head-on view of a bowl of apple pie ice cream drizzled with cider caramel and topped with a heart-shaped pie crust cookie with bowl of apple cider caramel in background

And then you’ll need to thank your lucky stars that you’re not lactose intolerant. Life could be so, so much worse. Unless, of course, you are lactose intolerant. And even then, I’m pretty sure there’s a pill you can take for that. Because who could resist what this ice cream is all about?

Landscape view of apple pie ice cream in red bowl with caramel drizzle and topped with a heart-shaped pie crust cookie with bowl of cider caramel in the background

This apple pie ice cream really does have all the elements of an apple pie and truly tastes like one, too. How have I never made pie crust cookies before??

View of apple pie ice cream in a bowl drizzled with caramel and topped with a heart-shaped pie crust cookie with more cookies and mac apple in the background

We’re officially in festive ice cream season and I couldn’t be more thrilled. Is it bad that I imagine a blizzard going on outside and while I’m snuggling up on the couch in front of the fireplace with a giant bowl of ice cream on my lap? Because to me, that is the life. I’ll probably be wearing some type of long underwear, too.

Close-up of apple pie ice cream drizzled with cider caramel and topped with heart-shaped pie crust cookie with an apple in the background

Does that sound like heaven to anyone else?? Heaven could also be that same scenario, but with a jar of apple cider caramel in my lap instead of a bowl of ice cream. And a spoon.

Do you have a favorite seasonal ice cream?

For more fall dessert recipes, check out my Apple Cider Cookies with Caramel or my Pumpkin Ice Cream with Pistachio Swirl.

5 from 1 vote
This Apple Pie Ice Cream has all the elements of your favorite seasonal treat: apple pie filling, apple cider caramel, and pie crust cookies. It will convince you to keep your ice cream machine out all fall and winter long!
Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel and Pie Crust Cookies
Prep Time
1 hr 30 mins
Cook Time
12 mins
Chill Time
8 hrs
Total Time
1 hr 42 mins
 

This Apple Pie Ice Cream has all the elements of your favorite seasonal treat: apple pie filling, apple cider caramel, and pie crust cookies. It will convince you to keep your ice cream machine out all fall and winter long!

Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: Apples, ice cream, Pie
Servings: 2 pints
Author: Sues
Ingredients
  • 2 apples, peeled, cored, and chopped
  • 1 Tbsp unsalted butter
  • 1 Tbsp all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup granulated sugar, divided
  • 1/2 tsp cinnamon
  • Pinch nutmeg
  • 1 Tbsp water
  • 1/2 Tbsp lemon juice
  • 1 1/2 cups whole milk
  • 4 large egg yolks
  • 2 cups heavy cream
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1 batch Apple Cider Caramel (recipe below)
  • 1 batch Pie Crust Cookies (recipe below)
Apple Cider Caramel
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 3 Tbsp unsalted butter, cut into 6 pieces
  • 1/3 cup heavy cream
  • 1/4 tsp cinnamon
  • Pinch salt
  • 1 Tbsp apple cider
Pie Crust Cookies
  • 1 1/4 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1 tsp granulated sugar, plus more for sprinkling
  • 1/2 tsp cinnamon, plus more for sprinkling
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted butter, chilled and cut into small pieces
  • 1/8-1/4 cup ice water
Instructions
  1. In a medium saucepan, combine chopped apples, along with butter, flour, 1/4 cup sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, water, and lemon juice over medium heat. Cook, stirring occasionally for about 4-6 minutes until the apples are slightly softened.

  2. Remove from heat and spoon apple mixture into a bowl. Cover and place in fridge to chill while preparing the rest of the ice cream.

  3. Heat milk and remaining 3/4 cup sugar in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Stir constantly, until the mixture just reaches the point of simmer. Remove from heat.

  4. Lightly whisk egg yolks in a separate medium bowl. Pour about half of the warm milk into the bowl with the egg yolks, whisking while you do so. Pour the egg/milk mixture back into the saucepan with the rest of the milk. Cook mixture over low heat, stirring constantly, until it thickens enough to coat the back of the spoon.

  5. In a separate medium-sized bowl, pour the heavy cream. Strain the egg/milk mixture into the heavy cream, making sure to continue to whisk. Stir in the vanilla. Cover with plastic wrap and place in the fridge for at least 4 hours. 

  6. Once mixture has been sufficiently chilled, process in ice cream maker according to manufacturer’s directions. When the ice cream is almost done hardening, mix in the apple mixture and cider caramel, making sure to reserve some of the caramel to drizzle over the finished ice cream.

  7. Scoop ice cream in airtight containers and place in the freezer for another 4+ hours, but ideally overnight.

  8. Serve ice cream in bowls with pie crust cookies and extra apple cider caramel drizzled over the top.

Apple Cider Caramel
  1. In a medium saucepan, heat granulated sugar over medium heat. Stir frequently with a rubber spatula until sugar turns into a smooth amber-colored liquid.

  2. Stir the butter into sugar. The mixture will bubble quite a bit. Stir for about 2 minutes, until the butter is completely melted.

  3. Stir the cream into the mixture and let it come to a boil. 

  4. Remove the saucepan from the heat and stir in cinnamon, salt, and apple cider. Pour the mixture into an airtight container like a mason jar. Store in fridge until you’re ready to use.

Pie Crust Cookies
  1. Put flour, sugar, cinnamon, and salt in the bowl of a food processor, and pulse to combine.

  2. Add small pieces of butter to the flour mixture. Process for about 10 seconds, until the butter resembles peas.

  3. Slowly add 1/8 cup of the ice water to the mixture while continuing to process, just until the dough holds together. Take care not to over process. If more water is needed, slowly add remaining 1/8 cup.

  4. Take dough from food processor, flatten on counter, wrap in plastic wrap, and chill for about an hour.

  5. Pre-heat oven to 375 degrees.

  6. On a lightly floured surface, roll the pie crust dough into a large round, about 1/4-inch thick. Cut dough into shapes of your choice and place them about 1/2-inch apart on a parchment paper-line cookie sheet. Gently beat the egg in a small bowl and brush egg wash on top cookie dough. Sprinkle additional sugar or cinnamon over the top. Bake for 10-12 minutes, until starting to turn golden brown.

  7. Place on a wire rack to cool completely. Once cooled, store in airtight containers until ready to use.

Recipe Notes
  • If you want to enjoy this apple pie ice cream without all the steps, feel free to buy store-bought caramel and cookies. You can also purchase pre-made pie dough to cut shapes out of and bake.

Apple Pie Ice Cream -- This Apple Pie Ice Cream has all the elements of your favorite seasonal treat: apple pie filling, apple cider caramel, and pie crust cookies. It will convince you to keep your ice cream machine out all fall and winter long | wearenotmartha.com #applepie #icecream #fall #apples

25 Responses to "Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel and Pie Crust Cookies"

  1. ah this ice cream looks amazing! And kind of glad to know I’m not the only one that needs an entire day to recover after just a couple of drinks!

  2. Joanne says:

    If I became lactose intolerant I would probably cry. Mostly because of having to give up ice cream. I mean, how could I resist this?!

  3. Megan says:

    I am lactose intolerant but would totally suffer through it for this dessert! Exceptions must be made. Ha. This looks amazing!

  4. Odetta says:

    Beautiful ice cream- I love all the fun touches!!!

  5. I am definitely in favor of fall ice cream flavors. This is incredible! You really went over the edge in a good way with all these components.

  6. Apple pie icecream with cider caramel? Sign me up! This sounds incredible! Such a creative dessert. I think I could eat about 10 bowls of this!

  7. Chris says:

    Even though it is almost midnight. I think I have everything I need to start making this tonight. I’m going to borrow your new ice cream tubs from Sur La Table.

  8. This apple pie ice cream looks SOOOO delish, I am craving A BIGGGGGGG bowl of this awesomeness!!!!!!!!!! ^_^

  9. Oh gosh…I can sum this recipe up in one word…YUM!!

  10. Monica says:

    I live in subconscious fear of becoming allergic to some favorite food category, too! Let’s not think about it! This ice cream looks so divine…I just churned some myself yesterday but nothing this amazing-looking!

  11. One word: perfection. Two words: Must have. Three words: I’m very hungry. YUM!

  12. Lexi says:

    Never more in my life have I wished that I had an ice cream maker…

  13. OMG Sues. This is incredible!! I’m an equal opportunist with ice cream – anytime, anywhere, no matter what temperature it is outside. This looks SO GOOD!! There was a period of time where I thought I had acid reflux, and the thought of giving up (or decreasing) lots of my favorite foods was seriously scary. Thankfully that’s behind me now, but so are the days of eating with wild abandon haha

  14. Yes ice cream is a blessing!!! Boy you made the best of it too. I can still remember the first time I ate French apple ice cream—-and that was a long long time ago. BUT it was outstanding and thus memorable. I think this wonderful combo falls in that category—-memorable.

  15. Your ice cream looks amazing. I’m so going to try making the caramel. Thanks for a great recipe 🙂

  16. this looks to die for. My local ice cream joint had one called autumn awesomeness which was cinnamon ice cream with apples, nutmeg, and apple cider DONUTS. So awesome.

  17. Meghan says:

    This looks absolutely amazing! And I hear you on the spicy food. I used to have a stomach of steel, not so much anymore!

  18. I am so with you about getting old! I remember going to Denny’s at 2 AM in college and eating the greasiest foods with no problem. I would definitely pay for that now! Ice cream is still my friend though, and this looks delicious!

  19. I need to skip lunch and have a big bowl of ice cream instead. Just last night I was thinking that it has been too long since I made homemade ice cream. Love the apple pie flavors!

  20. Victoria says:

    Pinned it! This is outstanding. I usually put away my freezer bowl once the freezing temps start to hit outside my door, but I’m really tempted to bring my ice cream maker out of hibernation for this one. Yum!!

  21. Justine says:

    Lovely!! Looks perfectly delish!

  22. House in Tillford says:

    yay for no lactose intolerance because that looks like a bowl of deliciousness!

  23. […] chocolate on top of the marshmallow and then drizzle some salted caramel sauce over the top. I used this recipe for the salted caramel, but omitted the cinnamon and cider and used 1 t salt. Also, it’s my […]

  24. […] favorites, but this Blood Orange Ginger Dark Chocolate Ice Cream is never far from my thoughts. And Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel? Omg yes. Oh, and by the way, this Triple Gingerbread Ice Cream is on my list for an update in the […]

  25. Mtngirl says:

    So this review is from someone who actually made the ice cream, lol. Yes, you all need to make this right now. I will say it definitely needs a longer than usual freezing time. I made it all in one day to serve for that night and it wasn’t all that ‘firm’ by dessert time. Not that anyone complained as they were licking every possible bit from the bowl. Thanks for a recipe that will be repeated (often).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *