Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts.psd

I used to think egg nog was one of those things you either love or hate. But then I realized I was not a lover or a hater, but an in-betweener. Do I get cravings to chug a huge cold glass of egg nog? Not usually. Do I enjoy the flavor and thinks it’s one of the most fabulous things about getting into the holiday spirit? Yes. And there’s so much more you can do with it than drink it if you’re just not a huge fan of the thick, creamy consistency. Like make doughnuts. I realize it’s still early November and some think it’s a crime to be posting holiday recipes. I swear, it’s Pinterest’s fault I’m in the spirit already. These days, most of my issues can be blamed on Pinterest.

But I’m also blaming Polar Seltzer and the fact that their winter flavors are out already. And one is Egg Nog.
Egg Nog Polar Seltzer.jpg

And it’s heavenly. Like, it’s hard to put my feelings about this into words, but basically, it’s egg nog without any of the thickness or calories. All amazing refreshing flavor. Now I just want to know what would happen if I mixed it with rum. See? My mind is always working.

I’d also like to place some of the blame for my early holiday cheer on Bigelow’s Eggnogg’n tea.
Bigelow Egg Nog Tea.jpeg

Again, all the flavor of egg nog without the thickness and calories. Plus you drink it hot, so it warms you up on cold winter nights. Or Fall nights. Whatever. My point is, it’s not too early.

But if you’re mad I’m posting holiday recipes already, please feel free to blame Pinterest, Polar Seltzer, and Bigelow. Thank you very much.

Anyway, back to the issue at hand. Egg nog. While I’m very much an egg nog in-betweener, Chris is most definitely an egg nog lover. Like I’ve never known someone who can drink so much of the stuff. So, I’ve been experimenting with some recipes to see what I can come up with involving egg nog all in the name of making the husband happy. But really just because I wanted to try putting egg nog in doughnuts. Fair enough, right?

I’d also like if you could all give a warm welcome back to my trusty old doughnut pan. You know, I kind of abandoned it for a while because, when I craved doughnuts, I craved real fried doughnuts. But then I decided if a doughnut involved egg nog, it could probably be A-OK baked. And I was right.

This recipe also has all the flavor of egg nog without all the thickness and… well, it does have the calories. But that’s OK because they’re totally worth it. I promise.

It also has rum. In both the doughnut and the icing. Because I would never let you down like that.

Spiked Egg Nod Doughnuts (makes 12):
Print this recipe!

  • 2 C all-purpose flour
  • 3/4 C sugar
  • 2 t baking powder
  • 1/2 t cinnamon
  • 1/2 t nutmeg
  • 1 t salt
  • 2 eggs
  • 3/4 C egg nog
  • 1 t rum
  • 2 T butter, melted
  • Spiked egg nog icing (see recipe below)

pre-heat oven to 325 degrees

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Ingredients.jpg

Whisk together flour, sugar, baking powder, cinnamon, nutmeg, and salt in a large bowl.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Flour.jpg

In a separate small bowl, whisk eggs. Then add in and whisk together egg nog, rum, and melted butter, until combined.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Wet Ingredients.jpg

Stir the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients, being very careful not to over-mix (that’s what causes the dense cakey doughnuts).

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Batter.jpg

Spray your doughnut pan with some cooking spray. Then fill the doughnut pan about 3/4 of the way with batter.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Dougnut Pan.jpg

And bake for about 8-10 minutes at 325 degrees. Doughnuts should be nice and springy to the touch.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Baked.jpg

Let cool in the pan for a few minutes and then remove. Re-spray the pan and pop the next batch in the oven (if your doughnut pan only holds 6 doughnuts like mine!).

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Baked 2.jpg

While doughnuts are baking and cooling, you can make the icing! It’s easy.

Spiked Egg Nog Icing:
Print this recipe!

  • 2 C confectioner sugar
  • 1 1/2 T butter, very soft
  • 2 T light rum
  • 1/4 t salt
  • 4-5 T egg nog

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Icing.jpg

Simply whisk all the ingredients together. If you find your icing is too thin, you can add more confectioner sugar; if it’s too thick, you can add more egg nog… OR rum. Whatever floats your boat. I used light rum for this part because I didn’t want my icing to turn a weird color.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts Icing Mixed.jpg

Once the doughnuts are totally cool, top with frosting. And some pretty sprinkles if you so desire.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 16.jpg

So, welcome to the holiday season. The weather in Boston has certainly been preparing us the last couple days. Brrrr. A glass of egg nog straight from the fridge might not warm you up, but I’m pretty sure a spiked egg nog doughnut would.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 9.jpg

This was definitely the BEST baked doughnut I’ve ever made. Of course, it still didn’t taste like a traditional fried doughnut, but I feel like fried AND egg nog would have been a little too much. Even for me. So, I liked that this was more of a cake doughnut. But it certainly wasn’t as dense and cakey as some doughnuts I’ve made in the past. Phew.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 15.jpg

There’s really nothing about these doughnuts that won’t make you happy. Or launch you into the holiday mood. And let’s face it; egg nog is pretty harmless in November when you consider I could be decking the halls with candy canes and Christmas trees. Don’t worry; that’s coming. You ain’t seen nothing yet!

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 10.jpg

Oh, but we can’t forget about the icing. Oh my God, the icing. It was sweet for sure, but also tasted distinctly like egg nog. And it had just an itty bitty teeny weeny touch of rum. Because if that doesn’t get you into the holiday spirit, I don’t know what will.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 11.jpg

I’m pretty excited for holiday drinks this year. And I’m sure I’ll be spiking up some egg nog and whipping up some creamy cocktails to welcome the holiday decorations, snow, and Christmas carols.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 14.jpg

But first, we’ll be celebrating Thanksgiving in just a few weeks (!!!). It’s my all-time favorite holiday and I plan on enjoying it to the fullest extent. But still, all egg nog concoctions are fully welcome at my Thanksgiving celebration.

Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts 4.jpg

Happy November 5 🙂

Are you an egg nog lover, hater, or in-betweener?


17 Responses to "Spiked Egg Nog Doughnuts"

  1. Gia Grossman says:

    Holy Yum Fest! Never too early for eggnoggy goodness in my mind…

  2. Michelle Collins says:

    We just bought that egg nog seltzer, too – I can’t wait to break it open! And I didn’t like egg nog until last year. Now, I’m borderline obsessed with it.

  3. Monique says:

    boozy doughnuts. You know the way to my heart.
    Polar seltzer is truly amazing. i want to know their secret! creamsicle and vanilla are my absolute faves!

  4. sweeter salt says:

    i love me some nog, but only in small doses. actually, i love it in coffee – so good. totally pinning these!


  5. Holly@Life as a Lofthouse says:

    I really need to invest in a donut pan. These sound AMAZING!!

  6. Erica says:

    I agree! I rarely want a whole glass of eggnog…but I enjoy eggnog flavored items. I need to find that polar. The donuts are so pretty and festive

  7. i don’t think i’ve ever had egg nog! how crazy is that? definitely need to fix that this year!

  8. LOVE LOVE! Perfect way to use eggnog!

  9. Christina says:

    I think it’s your duty as a food blogger to bring us recipes we’ll want to make for the upcoming season! Or maybe I just want some eggnog.

  10. Sharon says:

    These look incredibly beautiful and delicious…I once made egg nog french toast and it was a real hit…thanks for your inspiration, as usual!

  11. Meghan says:

    I LOVE the egg nog seltzer (also the butter rum)! Both are good with rum for a nice low cal cocktail.

  12. Therese (getpartychic.com) says:

    Ah, I’m totally going on the hunt for that Polar Seltzer Eggnog. Thanks for the tip!

  13. Reeni says:

    I’m an eggnog lover especially with a shot of rum in it! Your doughnuts are making me very happy! Eggnog is so yummy in desserts! I can’t get enough.

  14. Barbara says:

    Love egg nog! Will definitely be trying these inputs!

  15. Betty says:

    I’m an in-betweener as well. I love the egg nog flavor, but can only drink the stuff itself in small quantities. These doughnuts sound perfect. 🙂

  16. LisaR says:

    I Love Love Love Egg Nog!: regular, low fat, in shakes, ice cream – they even have Egg Nog-flavored Keifer! I splurge for the regular fat content around the holidays! : )

  17. Shannon says:

    oh yes please!! lactaid egg nog is the bomb, seriously try it 🙂 these donuts also sound awesome, in no small part because of the rum!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *